In some way my personal proposition happens against the basic and fundamental institution of marriage, but no matter if our company is and only relationship, as it is fitting of men just who create legislation for all those, you want to calmly envision people’s true condition. Taking into account one to legislation comes of truth, such people has actually united right here to type a structure and hookup ads posting sites Richmond therefore wipes brush the mistakes of the past and you will aims another type of road for future years, [thus] it is necessary which they judiciously study the latest conditions in our surroundings and you will reach the conclusion that there are something in the our life plus in our world that we simply cannot when you look at the in whatever way intimate our very own attention, that we need certainly to face valiantly. 51
Hernandez reasoned you to definitely mere judge sanction of an intimate commitment you will never be the only evidence that any particular one is a genuine and you will ethical citizen
I’ve visited the fresh new Set up so you can modestly protect, into best of my element, the fresh Cuban lady, the new married girl, the latest solitary woman, new light woman, the fresh new black girl, female of the many groups. I need to declare that there are a great number of Cuban women in difficult and you may embarrassing points, that as the honorable and also as deserving of quality because is actually other lady, that just because the the woman is from inside the a free of charge partnership, does not mean we should think about their and her loved ones depraved. 52
Because of the saying you to good disjuncture resided ranging from legislators’ ideals and you can “social facts,” Hernandez debated one to she try assaulting for Cubans who have been maybe not commonly said to be varieties of sexual propriety and you will, for this reason, have been unjustly disenfranchised
Twenty-two outside of the 60-half dozen Construction users probably brand new course chosen so you’re able to approve Hernandez’s proposal. Much of individuals who voted when you look at the choose reasoned it perform oblige males within the consensual unions meet up with a similar requirements and you may commitments you to definitely partnered men was indeed destined to fulfill and you will, ergo, carry out include all women and children. Such as, modern Construction affiliate Capablanca debated that “although it [Hernandez’s modification] looks paradoxical, far from getting…an attack to the wedding, it’s a coverage from it.” 53 He said, “Whenever men remember that he or she is guilty of female having who he’s good consensual union and also for the pupils that effect from these free unions, chances are they doesn’t practice consensual unions but in relationships.” 54 Capablanca illustrated men since almost inherently reckless, and you may implied that ladies needed Condition defense against them. Others echoed his rationale.
But not, most Assembly members, progressives and traditionals, balked in the Hernandez’s tip, arguing it absolutely was not that lead in order to popular improvements and you will would grant rights and you may benefits to help you undeserving, depraved citizens. Antique Construction member Cortina added a great competitive fight up against Hernandez’s proposition, shaping his dissent as a fight to own modernity, improvements, and you can civilization. The guy asserted that an effective constitutional be sure to look at consensual unions similar so you’re able to court marriages manage basically send Cuba away from toward an appropriate road divergent out-of regarding “all civilized nations in the world” and you can “wreck…brand new matrimonial program, while making [it] completely inadequate.” 55 Cortina prophesied, “Whether it amendment was indeed accepted, we might make a giant dilemma from inside the judge marriage, and now we create make effects of the governmental wave which we have simply lived through, in order to groups of our sentimental and you will nearest and dearest existence, [sectors] and therefore don’t need to be switched on radical and you can perturbing way that is advised.” 56 To own Cortina, the fresh 1933 wave is actually a governmental revolution, and after that change is always to just apply at politics: Social things will be remaining alone.
